Viewer Challenges Heather Gay on WWHL Over Black Eye Claims After Labeling Whitney Rose a ‘Liar’

During Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 3, Heather Gay made headlines when she woke up with a black eye. For an entire year, Heather maintained the same story: she had no idea what caused the injury. However, during the Season 4 reunion, she finally revealed the supposed truth—her black eye was allegedly the result of Jen Shah’s Sha-Mazing punch.

Now, fast forward to Season 5, where the tables have turned, and Heather is calling someone else out. This time, Whitney Rose is the one accused of lying, and Heather, along with a few other cast members, seems convinced that Whitney isn’t being truthful. The drama heated up even more when Heather appeared on Watch What Happens Live (WWHL), where a caller didn’t hesitate to point out the hypocrisy of her actions.

Heather Gay Confronted Over Double Standards

Heather Gay, who herself lied about her black eye for a year, found herself in the hot seat on WWHL. A fan called in, ready to confront her for accusing Whitney of lying while Heather had kept her own secret for so long.

@bravowwhl

Why Whitney saying she wasn’t a liar made Heather Gay so upset #RHOSLC

♬ original sound – BravoWWHL

Spoiler alert: Heather wasn’t having it. The fan asked, “Why were you so upset at Whitney for saying she’s not a liar when you lied about your black eye for over a year?” Heather responded quickly and confidently: “I’ve never said I wasn’t a liar. We were all telling Whitney that it was a ridiculous statement. Everyone has lied. No one has lived on this Earth without lying at least once. So when someone makes such an absolute claim, I’m going to challenge it.”

Season 5 Drama Intensifies

During the RHOSLC Season 5 premiere, Whitney found herself under fire. According to Heather, Whitney “chased” her out of a bar in Bermuda, yelling, “You exploited my vagina!” This, in Heather’s mind, made Whitney a liar.

Whitney, however, denied it all. “I have never lied,” she insisted. But Heather wasn’t buying it, laughing at Whitney’s claim. The other ladies quickly chimed in, sharing their own accusations of Whitney’s supposed dishonesty, leading to Whitney’s dramatic exit from the scene.

The Question Remains: Will Whitney Admit to Lying?

So, where does this leave us? Heather admits that everyone lies, including herself, but the question now is whether Whitney will own up to any of her alleged falsehoods. As the tension escalates, fans are left wondering: will Whitney confront her own truths, or will this drama continue to spiral?

Only time will tell as The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 5 unfolds. One thing is certain: the drama isn’t slowing down anytime soon.

Catch new episodes of Real Housewives of Salt Lake City every Wednesday at 9/8c on Bravo.